An export order is quoted in dollars, but the wages, the cloth and the rent are paid in rupees. When the rate moves between the quote and the payment, the profit moves with it, and it moves by far more than the rate does.
Why a small move is a large change
The profit is the small gap between what comes in and what went out. A change in the rate acts on the whole amount coming in, but the whole cost stays where it was. So a move that looks small against the rate is large against the profit.
A worked example
These figures are made up to show the sum. They are not a forecast and not a statement of any rate. The quote is $6.00 a garment. The cost is ₹430 a garment, in rupees. The rate at the time of the quote is assumed to be ₹85 to the dollar.
- At ₹85: 6 × 85 = ₹510. Profit ₹80 a garment, 15.7% of the price.
- At ₹84: ₹504. Profit ₹74, which is 7.5% less.
- At ₹83: ₹498. Profit ₹68, which is 15% less.
- At ₹82: ₹492. Profit ₹62, which is 22.5% less.
- At ₹80: ₹480. Profit ₹50, which is 37.5% less.
Each ₹1 on the rate is ₹6 a garment. On an order of 10,000 garments that is ₹60,000. The profit disappears at ₹430 ÷ 6 = ₹71.67 to the dollar.
Fixed cost in rupees, income in dollars
A ₹1 change in the rate is a 1.2% change in what comes in, and a 7.5% change in the profit. The thinner the profit, the larger the swing.
The wait makes it worse
The rate that matters is the one on the day the money arrives, not the day of the quote. If the buyer pays 60 days after shipping, the rate has 60 days more to move. The payment terms article counts what that wait costs in interest. The rate is a second cost of the same wait, and it can go either way.
What to do with it
- Find your break-even rate. Divide the rupee cost by the dollar price. Know how far the rate can fall before the order loses money.
- Quote with the rate in mind. Write down the rate the quote was based on, so a move can be seen against it.
- Ask how the rate is fixed. Ask your bank or your buyer whether the rate can be agreed at the time of the order. Do not assume it can.
- Watch the thin orders. A profit of ₹80 on ₹510 is thin. See markup and margin for how it is measured.
What the sums leave out
- Made-up numbers. The $6.00, the ₹430 and the ₹85 are assumptions. Use your own.
- Imported inputs. If part of the cost, such as cloth or trims, is itself priced in dollars, a move partly cancels. This article counts the whole cost in rupees.
- Bank charges and duties. They are not counted.
- The direction. The same rate move can also add to the profit.
To see what the cost per garment is before the rate comes in at all, use the garment costing calculator.