Business

Piece Rate or Salary: Who Carries the Efficiency Risk

Four folded cotton shirts in cream, beige, blue and charcoal in a row on a sage-green surface, beside a metal hand tally counter, a bundle of paper tickets tied with string and a pencil

A line can pay its operators by the day or by the garment. At the usual efficiency the two can be set to cost the same. The difference shows on a bad day and on an excellent one, and it is not only a difference in rupees: it decides who carries the loss when the line runs below its usual efficiency.

Two ways to pay

  • A daily wage. The operator is paid for the hours, whatever the output. The unit pays the same on a bad day, so the unit carries the risk. A good day is a gain for the unit.
  • A piece rate. The operator is paid a set amount for each good garment (or each good piece of an operation). The unit pays less on a bad day and more on a good one, so the operator carries the risk and shares the gain.

A worked example

These figures are made up to show the sum. They are not a benchmark, not a rate anybody should offer and not a claim about any unit. The line is the one in the cut-and-make rate article: 12 operators, 8 hours, an 18-minute SAM, ₹400 an hour, and ₹15,000 a day of running cost that does not change with the pay method. At 81.25% efficiency it makes 260 garments a day.

  • Daily wages: 12 × 8 × ₹400 = ₹38,400 a day.
  • Wage per garment at 260: 38,400 ÷ 260 = ₹147.69.

Now set a piece rate so that, at today's 81.25%, it costs exactly the same: ₹147.69 a garment, which over an 18-minute SAM is ₹8.21 for each standard minute. Everything below compares the two pay methods on the same line and the same style, changing only the efficiency.

What each costs per garment

Wage plus running cost, for the whole garment:

  • 65% (208 garments): daily wages ₹256.73, piece rate ₹219.81.
  • 75% (240): daily wages ₹222.50, piece rate ₹210.19.
  • 81.25% (260): ₹205.38 for both.
  • 90% (288): daily wages ₹185.42, piece rate ₹199.78.
  • 100% (320): daily wages ₹166.88, piece rate ₹194.57.

The daily-wage figures are the ones in the cut-and-make article. Under daily wages the cost per garment falls as efficiency rises, because the same ₹53,400 is spread over more garments. Under the piece rate the wage per garment never moves, so only the running cost is spread, and the cost falls much less.

Who carries the risk

At 65% the line on daily wages spends ₹53,400 for 208 garments; on the piece rate it spends 208 × 147.69 + 15,000 = ₹45,720. The unit is ₹7,680 a day better off on the piece rate. At 100% it is the other way round: the piece rate costs ₹62,262 against ₹53,400, and the unit gives up ₹8,862 a day.

That money does not disappear. It is the operators' pay. On the piece rate, each operator takes home, on average:

  • 65%: ₹2,560 a day, ₹640 less than the ₹3,200 of daily wages.
  • 75%: ₹2,954.
  • 81.25%: ₹3,200.
  • 90%: ₹3,545.
  • 100%: ₹3,938.
The choice is about who takes the bad day A bad day at 65% that is the line's fault, such as a bottleneck or waiting for cut parts, costs the operators ₹640 each on a piece rate. If the operators did not cause it, they will not accept it, and they should not have to.

What a piece rate needs before it works

  • Pay only for good pieces. A rework or a reject is not a garment. The rejects and rework article shows what one costs; a piece rate on every piece counted, good or not, pays operators to produce them.
  • A balanced line. Pay per operation rewards whoever sews fastest at their own post, including the one ahead of the slowest step, who earns more by piling bundles in front of it. See the line balancing article.
  • A measured SAM. The rate per standard minute is only as fair as the SAM. A guessed SAM underpays or overpays every operator on the line, and the disagreement comes later, in the pay.
  • A floor you can promise. Decide before the order what the lowest day's pay is, whether it is something you have agreed or something you must meet, and work out what that does to the sums above. The absent operator article shows how a day can fall for reasons no operator controls.

What the sums leave out

  • Made-up numbers. The wage, running cost, SAM and the 81.25% are assumptions. Use your own, measured.
  • Wage rules. What you may pay, and the minimum you must pay, depends on your agreements and the rules that apply to you. Ask someone who knows them before changing how a line is paid. This article is arithmetic, not advice on that.
  • New styles. The first days of a new style run below the usual efficiency. A piece rate set from an old style, applied on day one of a new one, takes that loss out of the operators' pay.
  • Mixed methods. A base wage with a payment above a target is a third option, and it moves the risk and the gain in between. The sum is the same: work out the day's pay at 65%, at the usual figure and at 100%.

Put your own operators, hours, SAM and output into the production efficiency calculator to find where your line runs, then run the three days above before choosing how it is paid.

Was this guide useful?

Read next

Related guides