Business

A Late Order: Pay the Penalty or Pay to Catch Up?

A white-faced alarm clock, a folded cream shirt tied with jute string like a parcel, and a roll of brown kraft tape in a row on a slate-blue background

The order is going to be late. The buyer's terms say what a late day costs, and the floor has two ways to catch up, both of which cost money too. Most owners pay whichever bill they dread least. The three can be put side by side in rupees, and the answer is not always "catch up".

Three ways to answer a late order

  • Pay the penalty. Deliver late and accept the deduction in the buyer's terms.
  • Catch up on the floor. Overtime, or a second crew, as in the overtime or a second shift article.
  • Pay to ship faster. The garments are ready late but travel quicker.

A worked example

These figures are made up to show the sum. They are not a benchmark, not a penalty any buyer charges and not a claim about any unit or any freight. The order is 1,000 garments at an assumed ₹850 each, so ₹8,50,000. The terms are an assumption: a deduction of 1% of the order value for each day late, ₹8,500 a day.

The line is the one in the operators for an order article, making 260 garments a day. It is 260 garments short, which is exactly one day of its output.

What each answer costs

  • Accept the penalty: the line finishes one day late. 1 day × ₹8,500 = ₹8,500.
  • Second crew: 12 operators for one 8-hour day at ₹400 an hour = ₹38,400.
  • Overtime at double: the figure in that same article, ₹76,800.
  • Ship faster (an assumed extra ₹60 a garment on the 260): ₹15,600. That works only if the buyer's date is for arrival and the garments can be ready in time to use it.

In this example the cheapest answer is to be a day late and pay ₹8,500. Catching up on the floor costs four to nine times as much to avoid it.

When the penalty is the dearer one

Turn it round. The penalty has to rise to the cost of the cure before the cure wins:

  • Against the second crew: ₹38,400 ÷ ₹8,50,000 = 4.5% of the order for each day late.
  • Against overtime: ₹76,800 ÷ ₹8,50,000 = 9.0% for each day.

And the penalty grows with the days. If the shortfall were 780 garments, three days of output, the deduction would be 3 × ₹8,500 = ₹25,500, but the cure would cost three times as much too. The comparison does not change; the scale does.

Put the penalty next to the cure before deciding Write the buyer's late terms and the cost of a second crew on the same page. One of them is cheaper, and it may not be the one that feels responsible.

What the sums leave out

  • Made-up numbers. The order value, the 1% a day and the freight are assumptions. Read your own terms, and get your own quote.
  • The buyer. A late order can cost the next order. That is a real cost and this sum does not price it. A buyer who gets a call before the date is in a different mood from one who finds out on it.
  • Other limits. Some buyers cancel instead of deducting, and some contracts say late is not allowed at all. Check what yours says.
  • Overtime has its own limits. The hours that may be worked, and what they must be paid, depend on your agreements and the rules that apply to you.

Work out how many garments you are short and how many a day the line makes in the production efficiency calculator, and the first line of this article, how many days late, follows from it.

Was this guide useful?

Read next

Related guides