Business

What an Hour of Machine Downtime Costs

A small steel oil can, a red pin cushion holding machine needles, a metal bobbin case and a small cleaning brush on a warm sand background

A machine stops and the mechanic is sent for. Everyone on the floor knows it is a loss, but few have the number. It is one operator's wage if the machine had room to spare, and the whole line's hour if it did not. The same hour can cost ₹400 or ₹6,675.

What stops when a machine stops

The line balancing article showed that a line makes only as many garments as its slowest step. A machine that goes down takes its operator's work with it. If that step had spare capacity, or the operator can move to another machine, the line hardly notices. If it was the slowest step, the line stops with it.

A worked example

These figures are made up to show the sum. They are not a benchmark, not a repair time and not a claim about any machine. The line is the one in the cut-and-make rate article: 12 operators, 8 hours, 260 garments a day, wages of ₹400 an hour and an assumed ₹15,000 a day for power, rent, supervision and the rest.

  • Wages for one hour: 12 × ₹400 = ₹4,800.
  • Running cost for one hour: ₹15,000 ÷ 8 = ₹1,875.
  • Together: ₹6,675 an hour.

In that hour the line would have made 260 ÷ 8 = 32.5 garments, at ₹205.38 each of making, which is ₹6,675 again. If the machine that stopped is the slowest step, one hour of downtime costs ₹6,675 and 32.5 garments. Half a day, four hours, is ₹26,700 and 130 garments.

When it costs less

If the machine is not the slowest step, the cost can be much lower. The operator moves to a spare machine, or the step has enough spare capacity to catch up the work later in the day. Then the loss is the idle wage at worst, ₹400 for the hour, and sometimes nothing. The absent operator article shows the same spread from ₹0 to a whole day, depending on the post.

Know your slowest step The same breakdown costs ₹400 on one machine and ₹6,675 an hour on another. The machine to keep running, and to keep a spare for, is the slowest one.

What a spare machine is worth

Assume a spare machine of the right type costs ₹30,000. That is an assumption, not a price. At ₹6,675 an hour it is paid for by ₹30,000 ÷ ₹6,675 = 4.5 hours of stoppage at the slowest step. If it is bought with a loan, put the amount and the rate into the machine EMI calculator and set the instalment against the hours it can save. A spare for a step with room to spare saves far less.

What to do with it

  • Write every stop down. The post, the time it stopped, the time it ran again. A month of that is your own cost of downtime, not mine.
  • Keep spares of the parts that your own log shows failing. A part on the shelf turns a morning into minutes.
  • Move the operator first, fix the machine second. Someone who can go to another machine at once costs the line nothing while the repair is done.
  • Look at the machine that stops most. The repair or replace article puts a number on the choice.

What the sums leave out

  • Made-up numbers. The wage, the ₹15,000, the ₹30,000 and the line are assumptions. Use your own.
  • The repair itself. The mechanic's bill and the parts are not counted.
  • Catching up. Making up a lost hour in overtime has a cost of its own; the overtime article puts a number on it.
  • Garments spoiled. A machine that fails in the middle of a seam can ruin the piece under the needle. The rejects article counts those.

Put your own operators, hours and output into the production efficiency calculator to see what an hour of your line is worth, then multiply it by the hours your machines stood last month.

Was this guide useful?

Read next

Related guides