Business

What a New Operator Costs in the First Month

A coiled yellow measuring tape, a wooden thread spool, a small pair of steel scissors and a blank spiral notepad with a pencil on a dusty-rose background

A new operator is paid from the first day and sews at the standard only after some weeks. In between, the wages are real and the garments are not. The gap is rarely written down, so it is paid without being counted. It can be counted in four lines.

What "paid but not earned" means

An operator working at the standard earns, for the unit, one garment's worth of making every standard time. A beginner working at 40% of the standard turns out 40% as many garments for the same wage. The other 60% of that wage bought nothing.

The sum Wages paid − (garments made × the wage in one garment at the standard).

A worked example

These figures are made up to show the sum. They are not a benchmark, not a wage anybody should pay and not a claim about how fast anybody learns. The operator is paid ₹400 an hour for 8 hours, ₹3,200 a day, over 6 days a week. The garment's standard time is the 18 minutes of the line efficiency article, so an operator at the standard makes 8 × 60 ÷ 18 = 26.7 garments a day, and the wage in one garment is ₹3,200 ÷ 26.7 = ₹120. The weekly efficiencies are an assumption: 40%, 60%, 80% and then the standard.

Week by week

  • Week 1 at 40%: wages ₹19,200 for 64 garments, which are worth ₹7,680 of making. Paid but not earned: ₹11,520.
  • Week 2 at 60%: 96 garments, ₹11,520 earned. Paid but not earned: ₹7,680.
  • Week 3 at 80%: 128 garments, ₹15,360 earned. Paid but not earned: ₹3,840.
  • Week 4 at the standard: nothing lost.

Together: ₹23,040, which is 192 garments that the same wages would have made at the standard — about seven days of one operator's pay. In week 1 each garment the beginner makes carries ₹300 of wages, against ₹120 for a trained operator.

Where it shows up

It does not show as a line on any bill. It shows as a line that runs a little below its usual efficiency for a month. If the new operator is at the slowest step, it also drags the whole line, as in the line balancing article, and the loss is far larger than one operator's wages.

What to do with it

  • Put the beginner on a post with spare capacity. The same weak week costs the line nothing if the operation was not the slowest.
  • Start with the simple operations, and move up as the numbers rise. The cost above is for a beginner on a job that fits them.
  • Measure the weeks. Count the beginner's garments each day for a month, and the table above is yours, not mine.
  • Keep the cost in the quote. If one operator in twelve is always new, some of this is part of the cost of making, as in the cut-and-make rate article.

What the sums leave out

  • Made-up numbers. The wage and the four weekly figures are assumptions. People learn at different speeds, on different jobs.
  • Someone's time. A supervisor or a neighbour who teaches is not sewing. That time is not counted.
  • Rework. Beginners make more mistakes. The rejects article puts each one in rupees.
  • Who leaves. Wages paid to someone who goes in the third week are gone. It is the strongest reason to keep the people already trained.

Put your own operators, hours and output into the production efficiency calculator to see where the line runs now, then compare it with a day that has a new operator on it.

Was this guide useful?

Read next

Related guides